Followers of the Magpies are progressively regarding their manager's outfit as a fickle ally. When everything clicks, they transform into the undisputed life of the party, producing breathtaking performances. But, at other times, key players like their midfield linchpin and his teammates simply go missing.
Compounding this issue is a second-half strategy laced with a worrying tendency of panic. Before their trip to Manchester United, the facts paint a sobering tale: they have squandered 13 crucial Premier League points from winning situations this term and are without a clean sheet in 10 consecutive games across all competitions. Securing victory at Old Trafford would represent only their second domestic success on the travel this year.
Conversely, defeat has been tasted on one occasion in their most recent six league fixtures, and despite sitting in a seemingly lowly 11th spot, they remain a mere six points off the coveted top four. Add in an looming two-part League Cup semi-final against Manchester City and a strong chance of advancing to the Champions League knockout phase, and it is simpler to appreciate the gaffer's measured hope.
“Our issues aren't limited to issues,” remarked the team's head coach. “There are strengths as well. My glass is very much optimistic at present. I understand outside observers might have a different take, but I feel we are making progress.”
The puzzle persists: can this collection of players match – or perhaps exceed – the heights of last season's Wembley triumph and fifth-place standing? Balancing a hectic schedule makes this difficult.
This tiredness might be the reason behind the inability to uphold a stellar opening 45-minute performance versus their London rivals, eventually surrendering a 2-0 lead to tie 2-2. Likewise, it could be the reason for a subdued performance in a painful defeat to arch-rivals Sunderland, where the team appeared off the pace just days after a grueling European excursion.
While coaching is clearly the manager's forte, the constant grind of twice-weekly football has drastically reduced valuable coaching time. This impedes the team's stylistic adaptation to operating with summer signing their number nine up front, instead of the departed Alexander Isak. Although immensely talented, the German forward has not shown the same searing counter-attacking pace or intense pressing.
Indeed, the side's signature high press has at times failed. Injuries to crucial engine Joelinton have exacerbated matters, while big-money signings Anthony Elanga and Jacob Ramsey have had difficulties settling since their combined £90m+ moves.
If a switch to a 3-5-2 could theoretically benefit the cause, a worsening backline absence list makes that unlikely. Important full-backs will be missing for the upcoming crucial fixtures, further testing the squad's resilience.
When playing at their high-tempo best, they appear almost unplayable. The issue is sustaining that intensity for the entire 90 minutes. The often-seen alternative approach of sitting back into a deep-lying defensive shape has sometimes been self-destructive.
“That match descended into chaotic at 2-2,” said the coach. “However the intention was trying to win. We always try to win.”
What seems called for is a balanced approach – involving better ball control, a midfield capable of slowing the pace, and a sensible willingness to sometimes settle for a draw. Yet, a ambition to compete on every competitions is testing limited squad options to their limit.
It may seem sacrilegious to some, but a different strategy in the cup competitions earlier could have alleviated the present fixture pile-up. Amid critical Champions League & league matches on the horizon, the imperative to strategically choose focus areas is growing increasingly apparent.
The manager recognized the size of the journey remaining. “Being involved a club of this size, the pressures are big. Each game is critical. There is progress to be made in the league. We are in the Carabao Cup last four, we want to progress in the Champions League and perform in the FA Cup.
“We're moving in the right direction, but we have lots of improvement to do to transform into the regularly winning team we envision. Our capacity to put winning runs has deserted us this season.
“The task is to attain those heights we know we're able to reach. The internal belief is that the confidence to do that is coming back. Yet now we have to demonstrate it. It's not all bad right now, but the next few weeks will shape a lot.”
Elena is a certified nutritionist with 10 years of experience in sports supplementation and wellness coaching.